Forum:Do Villains Deserve Death?

From the Kingdom Hearts Wiki: A world of information not accessible by Gummiship
Jump to navigationJump to search
Realm of Sleep Forum Logo.png
Forums: Index > The Realm of Sleep > Do Villains Deserve Death?


SoraHalloweenTalk.png
UxieLover1994 Tiempo de morder de nuevo con el poder! El tema de hoy: su sorpresa! — 02:54, 31 March 2011 (EDT)
710MS.png I've been interested in Crime and Punishment since I was a little girl, and I'm asking: do all villains in this series deserve death? I think they only deserve death if they have too much darkness or have commeted a murder:
  • Lady Tremaine and her daughters deserve to be killed, because they attempted to murder Cindy, plus I also beleave that they murdered her father to make her their slave.
  • Since the Evil Queen poisoned Snow White, she deserved to be chased off a cliff and be crushed by a huge piece of stone.
  • Clayton attempeted to kill the Gorillas, so he deserves to be "Crushed by Darkness". This is no longer cannon... to me.
  • Since the Queen of Hearts kept on killing people by beheading them when they don't agree with her, she deserves to lose her head.
  • Jafar wanted to destroy Agrabah, so he deserved what he got: becoming a genie, then later slain by Sora and Carpet.
  • Ursula was hungry for power over the seven seas, and would trick anyone so she can get her way. She got what she deserved, as said by Sora himself during Ursula's Revenge.
  • Shan-Yu really wanted to take over China, and even appeared to let the darkness in his heart overtake him.
  • Barbossa just wanted to be free from his curse. Though he appears to not deserve death, he did steal the Black Pearl and is assumed to have murdered 881 people.
  • Scar murdered Mufasa just because he was hungry for power, and even told everyone that Simba has also been killed. He got the same fate as the Tremaines: Overtaken by Darkness, since he became a Heartless.
  • Because of their evil sins and the way they were able to conquer Hollow Bastion for a small while, Sark and the MCP deserve to be deleated. Besides, the one who created them many years ago was also pure evil.

Note: This only applies to Disney Villains. And also, Captain Hook and Gantu do not deserve death, while Hades is immortal and Ooggie Boogie is nothing but a bag of bugs.


Would you care to explain why Hook doesn't deserve death? After all, he and Barbossa are both pirates out to steal treasure, and based on the fact that he has treasure, we could assume that he took it from someone, probably killing them. Anyway, Sark and MCP weren't doing anything of their own free will, they were just doing what their programming told them to (like a computer program would have to), placing the blame with Xehanort, not themselves. A few others, Shan-Yu was far from the first and far from the last person to want to take over China, or Europe, or America, or Africa, or Asia, or the whole world. Does this mean he should die for it? Did Napolean deserve to die? Did Caesar? What about George III? Just because there are a few Hitlers and Stalins doesn't mean that everyone who wants power is a homicidal maniac. Other than that, I think you shouldn't just shrug off Oogie Boogie, I mean, yeah, he's a sack of bugs, but Sark and MCP are just a bunch of 1's and 0's, that didn't keep you from including them. --205.209.95.137 08:50, 1 April 2011 (EDT)