User talk:EduardoKH

From the Kingdom Hearts Wiki: A world of information not accessible by Gummiship
Jump to navigationJump to search
The ultimate battle for KINGDOM HEARTS is upon us.
Box Art KHIII.png We hope you enjoy your time on the Kingdom Hearts Wiki! Before you contribute, please see the following:
  • Traverse Town is our community portal. It lists current Wiki events and contains important information.
  • Help:Guide for New Members states how this Wiki is run. It is a useful starting point for beginners.
  • Help:Editing provides tutorials on basic Wiki markup.
  • The Word That Never Was is where users go to discuss Wiki-related issues. Your input would be greatly appreciated!
  • Your userpage is the place to tell others about yourself, if you wish to do so. In need of inspiration? See the Userpage Guide!
  • If you have any questions, please ask our administrators for help. Remember to sign any posts you leave on their talk pages with four tildes ("~~~~")!

Thank you for joining the Kingdom Hearts Wiki community! We look forward to working with you. May your heart be your guiding key!

UxieLover1994 07:02, 29 December 2012 (UTC)

UxieLover1994 Nya? — 07:02, 29 December 2012 (UTC)
678MS.png Hey there, and welcome to the KHWiki.


I saw that you were new and wanted to welcome you too, so hi :) --♥ Somi ♥ (talk)

Real-world locations[edit]

Sorry for the wait.

The main problem with what you were adding is that it was trivia style. Writing what is essentially "this KH location is totally real" does not look professional, and adds no information besides what the existence of the header does.

Secondly, you did not edit it with references to specific sources, except for the Mulan quote, nor did you follow the comments on the article. Instead of providing actual quotes, you just listed the game that you had claimed the location appeared in, without actually providing the necessary evidence.

Next, Big Ben is not explicitly named in Kingdom Hearts as far as I know, and if you want to claim that it is, you need to provide the source. Simply matching the look of a real-world area isn't enough for this page.

Finally, the journal notes are not relevant. They are clearly presented as non-canon notes so that the player knows where the characters came from.

Since you were making the same mistakes as the first time, you were reverted for the same reasons; that's why we didn't present new ones.

To clarify what should be on the page:

  • Coverage of the real-world location's purpose within the plot.
  • Full quotes from either the games or official material, properly formatted, which explicitly mention the real-world location."We're werewolves, not swearwolves." (KrytenKoro) 05:47, 10 January 2013 (UTC)
"Full quotes from either the games or official material, properly formatted, which explicitly mention the real-world location."
Quotes used as citations need to be in proper citation style, as I rewrote the quote, and not in byline style. The properly coded quote is still in the page code, but it is hidden because there is nothing for it to be used on right now."We're werewolves, not swearwolves." (KrytenKoro) 23:13, 10 January 2013 (UTC)
Okay, clarification on the citations: we're not going to delete sections just because they don't have the citations. The issue though is that we do eventually need citations, and they need to be proper format. Merely stating "Big Ben is totally real" is a bit unprofessional, and redundant to the fact that we already list that location on the article. It's little better than the header.
Take a look at the cited quotes for Shibuya and China. That's the kind of thing we want in regards to citations."We're werewolves, not swearwolves." (KrytenKoro) 04:02, 13 January 2013 (UTC)