Forum:More Walkthrough Matters: Difference between revisions
From the Kingdom Hearts Wiki, the Kingdom Hearts encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
{{The Inexistent|dusk='''I feel hosting them off- wiki would be completely pointless. It would just be easier to host them here. Hosting them off- wiki would demoralize editors, be less illustrative, and ''extremely'' redundant. If you read the meeting logs, I listed several other reasons there. But every time I asked, it was never answered. ''Why'' host on SW? Is there a good reason? I do not feel that there is.'''}} | {{The Inexistent|dusk='''I feel hosting them off- wiki would be completely pointless. It would just be easier to host them here. Hosting them off- wiki would demoralize editors, be less illustrative, and ''extremely'' redundant. If you read the meeting logs, I listed several other reasons there. But every time I asked, it was never answered. ''Why'' host on SW? Is there a good reason? I do not feel that there is.'''}} | ||
* I'm not voting, as I'm just suggesting an alternative. But to answer the question of why, the basic goal of StrategyWiki is to have the best, most detailed, fully illustrated guides on the net for "every" game. Having some of the biggest fans of the Kingdom Hearts series, combined with the experience/skills of the guide writers/layout people at StrategyWiki, could create some very nice guides. The goal is to be a single stop for anyone looking for a game guide. If they want more in depth information, they're pointed to Kingdom Hearts (or the relevant series' wiki). And vice versa, if the person is looking for guides, they can come to SW, and find guides for whatever game they need. -- [[User:Prod|Prod]] 20:24, 8 August 2011 (UTC) | * I'm not voting, as I'm just suggesting an alternative. But to answer the question of why, the basic goal of StrategyWiki is to have the best, most detailed, fully illustrated guides on the net for "every" game. Having some of the biggest fans of the Kingdom Hearts series, combined with the experience/skills of the guide writers/layout people at StrategyWiki, could create some very nice guides. The goal is to be a single stop for anyone looking for a game guide. If they want more in depth information, they're pointed to Kingdom Hearts (or the relevant series' wiki). And vice versa, if the person is looking for guides, they can come to SW, and find guides for whatever game they need. -- [[User:Prod|Prod]] 20:24, 8 August 2011 (UTC) | ||
{{KrytenKoro|We have the images, infrastructure, and links here, and we already have many pieces of walkthroughs and appendix material, like [[Mythril]] or [[Blitz]]. It doesn't make sense to have a collected, centralized version of all that material that is not on our wiki. Furthermore, placing the walkthrough on a separate wiki makes it much more cumbersome for editors to keep track of the edits that are occuring to the walkthroughs. | |||
The goal of our wiki's walkthroughs is to be fully comprehensive. As far as I know, that jives with strategywiki's scope. If strategywiki is willing to have the walkthroughs be regularly '''''synced''''' between the wikis (same articles on both wikis, so that they can be worked on by editors from both wikis without requiring anyone to lurk a wiki they aren't already), then that is a perfectly acceptable option. But it simply makes no damn sense to have the walkthrough there and not here. | |||
Summary: The walkthrough ''must'' be here. It can also be there if they want it.}} |
Revision as of 20:54, 8 August 2011
Forums: Index > The World that Never was > More Walkthrough Matters
|
Votes to have walkthroughs off- wiki
Please post where you would rather host them in your vote
Votes to have walkthroughs at khwiki.net
Discussion
|
- I'm not voting, as I'm just suggesting an alternative. But to answer the question of why, the basic goal of StrategyWiki is to have the best, most detailed, fully illustrated guides on the net for "every" game. Having some of the biggest fans of the Kingdom Hearts series, combined with the experience/skills of the guide writers/layout people at StrategyWiki, could create some very nice guides. The goal is to be a single stop for anyone looking for a game guide. If they want more in depth information, they're pointed to Kingdom Hearts (or the relevant series' wiki). And vice versa, if the person is looking for guides, they can come to SW, and find guides for whatever game they need. -- Prod 20:24, 8 August 2011 (UTC)
|