14,935
edits
KHWiki:Pages for deletion/Archives/2009 AprJun: Difference between revisions
KHWiki:Pages for deletion/Archives/2009 AprJun (edit)
Revision as of 13:52, 10 February 2021
, 3 years agoText replacement - "[[Kingdom Hearts Wiki:" to "[[KHWiki:"
(replaced: ’ → ' (11), typos fixed: … → ... (3), June of 2009 → June 2009, comming → coming, seperate → separate (2), it's own → its own, a admin → an admin) |
m (Text replacement - "[[Kingdom Hearts Wiki:" to "[[KHWiki:") |
||
| Line 121: | Line 121: | ||
{{Zexion14|text=I tried to create an article on the creater of the series this site is founded on, and I can see so did several others. During my creation of the article it was nominated for deletion, User:Guardian Soul says that this wiki is only for subjects whith in the game universe, that doesn't seem right to me, the Final fantasy wiki has a page for [[http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Hironobu_Sakaguchi Hironobu Sakaguchi]] So why shouldn't we have one for Nomura. I think that an article like this is very important, and it would be usefull to have it on the site. So please help me save my article!!!!!!!}} | {{Zexion14|text=I tried to create an article on the creater of the series this site is founded on, and I can see so did several others. During my creation of the article it was nominated for deletion, User:Guardian Soul says that this wiki is only for subjects whith in the game universe, that doesn't seem right to me, the Final fantasy wiki has a page for [[http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Hironobu_Sakaguchi Hironobu Sakaguchi]] So why shouldn't we have one for Nomura. I think that an article like this is very important, and it would be usefull to have it on the site. So please help me save my article!!!!!!!}} | ||
{{TNE|blahtext=Perhaps you didn't read the [[ | {{TNE|blahtext=Perhaps you didn't read the [[KHWiki:Manual of Style|Manual of Style]]. The wiki should only contain articles within the KH universe. And then again, if we were to bring in the Nomura article, where do you think we'd get most, if not all of our info from ?}} | ||
{{Zexion14|text=I see your point now, and you were right I didn't read the Manual of Style, even though I do think that an article on the man that created the series would be important, but it is not my place to disobay the rules of the wiki. | {{Zexion14|text=I see your point now, and you were right I didn't read the Manual of Style, even though I do think that an article on the man that created the series would be important, but it is not my place to disobay the rules of the wiki. | ||
| Line 707: | Line 707: | ||
::Bugger, I just found this discussion. I would like to say that the plot sections of each of the three are identical, the "youmay" bit to the enemy page doesn't work as well; they fight as one boss fight, and their enemy page treats them as one unit, and the individual pages are a mess (see [[Shock (Character)]]'s journal section). There doesn't seem to have been any improvement in splitting the pages, and it creates three really terrible disambig pages (Shock has one just because of "Thunder"? Really?), and the page title's aren't in line with how we do character articles. The character articles don't even link to the other two members of the trio until the very last sentence (and not even in a "See Also"). The split articles are just a gigantic mess at this point.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 00:37, 19 June 2009 (UTC) | ::Bugger, I just found this discussion. I would like to say that the plot sections of each of the three are identical, the "youmay" bit to the enemy page doesn't work as well; they fight as one boss fight, and their enemy page treats them as one unit, and the individual pages are a mess (see [[Shock (Character)]]'s journal section). There doesn't seem to have been any improvement in splitting the pages, and it creates three really terrible disambig pages (Shock has one just because of "Thunder"? Really?), and the page title's aren't in line with how we do character articles. The character articles don't even link to the other two members of the trio until the very last sentence (and not even in a "See Also"). The split articles are just a gigantic mess at this point.[[User:KrytenKoro|<small>Glorious</small>]] [[User_talk:KrytenKoro|<small>CHAOS!</small>]] 00:37, 19 June 2009 (UTC) | ||
:::Yeah... I agree with Kryten, there was a discussion in the Talk page there but it got deleted as well XD! And I miserably failed to express my opinion here >.>. On another note, I found [[Lock, Shock and Barrel]] which is a redirect page to Lock, Shock, and Barrel which just got deleted, guess it should be deleted as well if we're not planning to bring back the page with the three characters instead of three separate pages (I still vote for a single article for the three of them tho) '''EDIT:''' Actually I just found a lot of redirect pages in [[ | :::Yeah... I agree with Kryten, there was a discussion in the Talk page there but it got deleted as well XD! And I miserably failed to express my opinion here >.>. On another note, I found [[Lock, Shock and Barrel]] which is a redirect page to Lock, Shock, and Barrel which just got deleted, guess it should be deleted as well if we're not planning to bring back the page with the three characters instead of three separate pages (I still vote for a single article for the three of them tho) '''EDIT:''' Actually I just found a lot of redirect pages in [[KHWiki:Needed Articles]] (Didn't know that existed XD!). I guess those need burnination as well... need me to list them? --[[User:Yer mom|Yer mom]] 19:27, 19 June 2009 (UTC) | ||
::::Please do. I will restore the page and redirect the individual pages. -[[User:Azul81677|<font color="#4682B4">Azul</font>]] <sup><small>('''''[[User talk:Azul81677|talk]] ・[[Special:Contributions/Azul81677|contribs]]''''')</small></sup> 22:15, 19 June 2009 (UTC) | ::::Please do. I will restore the page and redirect the individual pages. -[[User:Azul81677|<font color="#4682B4">Azul</font>]] <sup><small>('''''[[User talk:Azul81677|talk]] ・[[Special:Contributions/Azul81677|contribs]]''''')</small></sup> 22:15, 19 June 2009 (UTC) | ||