14,793
edits
Forum:Questions pertaining to the Walkthrough space: Difference between revisions
Forum:Questions pertaining to the Walkthrough space (edit)
Revision as of 01:13, 8 May 2011
, 13 years agono edit summary
Chitalian8 (talk | contribs) (Whoops, I didn't write that.) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 61: | Line 61: | ||
I'm liking As If!'s idea on the way to organize strategies, but I just thought of something. Should we use actual users' names? A Wiki shouldn't have certain pages "signed" by the users that contributed to them (That's why we raised hell over the way Oasis displays the user that added a particular image, no?). If we organize it that way, perhaps we should say "Strategy A" and "Strategy B" instead of "Erry's Strategy" and "Af If!'s Strategy". Just a thought.}} | I'm liking As If!'s idea on the way to organize strategies, but I just thought of something. Should we use actual users' names? A Wiki shouldn't have certain pages "signed" by the users that contributed to them (That's why we raised hell over the way Oasis displays the user that added a particular image, no?). If we organize it that way, perhaps we should say "Strategy A" and "Strategy B" instead of "Erry's Strategy" and "Af If!'s Strategy". Just a thought.}} | ||
{{ErryTalk|time=21:13, 7 May 2011 (EDT)|cj=Here's my 2¢ | |||
*'''How are the walkthroughs supposed to be structured?''' Is it going to be '''Page 1: INSERT WORLD HERE''' or '''Page 1: INSERT GAME HERE'''? | |||
Well, I suggest each game has it's own page, while in the actual walkthrough, it would be structured in how the story would allow it, such as when in KH2, you would have to visit worlds twice. So it would be, for KH2, Twilight Town (Roxas) -> Twilight Town 1st Visit -> Hollow Bastion 1st Visit, etc. That way it would be organized. and the chapters (essentially the worlds) would be collapsible. | |||
*'''How are the walkthroughs supposed to be written — in the first person, or the third person?''' | |||
Third person, such as 'you' and not 'the player'. Because that way it is better explained to the reader, rather than reading it to yourself. | |||
*If there are more than one solution to a boss fight or a sidequest, for instance, '''how many must be shown?''' | |||
**My suggestion is three — either the most popular, or the most feasible. | |||
**If we go with it (I'm not obliging anyone to go with it, really), then how is it meant to be displayed? As collapsible sections, or as tabs? I recommend the latter, but again, it's up to all of you. | |||
I have no personal preference, I am okay with either tabs or collapsibles... but tabs for the better layout of the walkthrough article.}} | |||