File talk:Shadow Roxas KHII.png


 * It's not "fan-posed", this render uses an actual ingame animation, it's the same as using a cropped screenshot. I uploaded it over the "official" image because this one is merely a placeholder and not depicting Shadow Roxas in any shape or form. If it really bothers you that much revert it, but there is really not need for a separate images that isn't used anywhere. -- 15:44, 12 December 2014 (UTC)
 * If you made the image, then technically it's "fan-ANYTHING." I agree with you that this image does a better job at illustrating what Shadow Roxas is, but I feel that Square Enix's material always should go above and before our own personal preferences. - 18:23, 12 December 2014 (UTC)
 * If it's using an in-game animation, I wouldn't be willing to call it fan-posed -- Shard is ripping a model that exists in the game, as it exists in the game. I think it's much more problematic to treat the fan-made poses such as Sora doing a funny walk as if they were official -- this here is basically a more powerful screenshot. 21:40, 12 December 2014 (UTC)
 * Hence I suggested we separate the files. I am in full agreement that Shard's rip is better. But I also do not think we should ignore the existence of the official render, no matter how crappy it looks. -